220 Comments
founding

Its deeply ironic that the millionaire “fighting for little guy” ends up getting in a fight with the janitor. That encapsulates this strange elitist rebellion against the working class we’re living through.

I just donated to the guy. I hope others do too and he keeps his job.

Expand full comment

Time for Mr Torres to sue the wanna be revolutionary. In a court located in his neighborhood. And since NY judges and juries love huge damages let's hope Mr Torres and Carlson can trade places.

Expand full comment

Definitely! Sue those bastards for false imprisonment and intentional infliction of emotional distress. Sue the school for negligence.

Expand full comment

Alan Dershowitz said he'll take any case involving a suit against Columbia pro bono.

Give him a call, Mr. Janitor.

Expand full comment

I just read that his union is suing Columbia.

Expand full comment

Good. And hopefully also named are the hamas profs and administrators

Expand full comment

Sue Hamas as international lawyers are suing other terrorists groups and winning…see Prager U. website for great information!!

Expand full comment

Hurray for the local union and may they persevere against certain leftist movements in the AFLCIO & UAW that are circulating petitions against Israel ie refusing to manufacture or load any products being sent or received to/from Israel, support divestment, and condemn Israel for committing genocide.

Expand full comment

Excellent!

Expand full comment

Unfortunately, Democratic judges and juries in NY and other blue cities no longer support working people in low wage jobs. They are the party of the rich and are owned by them.

Expand full comment

That's why I want a jury of those on Mr Torres neighborhood to be jurors. To send a message. A big one

Expand full comment

That would indeed be sweet to see!

Expand full comment

ABSOLUTELY SUE THE MILLIONAIRE IN ADDITION TO COLUMBIA

Expand full comment

YES! Great idea!

Expand full comment

Media outlets and social media trolls are definitely going to come after him. Even in their bubbles, they'll realize this is an unsustainably bad look for them. It's only a matter of time until we get a story with a title like "The Janatorial Face of White Supremacism" to explain why we shouldn't believe our lying eyes.

Expand full comment

George Zimmerman, white hispanic

Expand full comment

For real

Expand full comment

Even though the janitorial face is a POC!

Expand full comment

Being a "POC" is always conditional to how well you reiterate leftist talking points

Expand full comment

Not so different to being Jewish.

Expand full comment

Schrodinger’s Race.

Expand full comment

Exactly! He will be considered white Hispanic, because that's more convenient!!

Expand full comment

And the leftists are overwhelmingly white people funded by their affluent families, as well as by ultra rich white subsidizers of anti American movements.

Expand full comment

This is nothing new. Just like the Weather Underground murdering a Brinks security guard and two police officers in the name of liberating the working class.

Expand full comment

Deep irony indeed. They want to be a “revolutionary” for people across an ocean and don’t care who they stomp on right here in front of them. And yet, the same types tend to be against any “meddling” of US in foreign countries, telling us we should care more about what goes on in our own country. Our really? How can you tell me that when you can’t even think about how your little building takeover affects janitors, affects the community, affects the people responsible for cleaning up after you make a mess? And who is going to pay for all the damage you create?

How can you claim to care about the lowly Palestinian when you can’t even see the common man standing right next to you?

Expand full comment

What is even worse is that the "revolutionary" walked away with his teeth intact.

Expand full comment

These morons are pressing their luck like Moe Greene.

Expand full comment

“40 year old trust fund kid”. Translation-Scumbag.

Expand full comment

It’s this simple: Carrying the oppressor / white privilege / equity argument to its logical end, said “trust fund kid” can only live the principle by distributing 100% of his inheritance. But since that’s hard, jetting on to campus to play comrade is both exhilarating and helps ameliorate that pesky guilt.

Expand full comment

People that inherit wealth often end up having self-esteem problems. Whereas when you must work to achieve something you respect yourself more. A generalization naturally.

Expand full comment

Why is he a scumbag? Someone else gifted him money. He had no choice in the matter. His status as a trust fund recipient had nothing to do with who he is or his decision making, did it?

Expand full comment

He's a 40 year old protesting at a college campus, breaking into buildings. Though the protests are nominally about Gaza, they've also slipped into a whole variety of "settler-colonialist" and other Marxist complaints, which paints this patrician as something of a hypocrite.

Expand full comment
May 7·edited May 7

Agreed. I just don't like people jumping to conclusions about who a person is based on their wealth.

All too often people start from a position of negativity or assuming malicious intent. We would all be wise to begin treating our neighbors as friends, not enemies.

Of course, the guy in question has gone beyond that and proven he isn't a friend.

Expand full comment

Good point. I always hated the term "the 1%," an attempt to "other" a class of people that have hardly any similarities beyond their income.

Expand full comment

What planet are you from? He’s a scumbag because he’s not using his money to help good causes…instead he’s abusing his money to play at caring about others. When a jury divests him of all of his money we’ll see how much time he has on his hands to play political games…

Expand full comment

Audrey, your comment is a great example of what I'm talking about.

What planet am I from? The same planet as you. We're "neighbors".

You called him a scumbag because you don't think he is spending his money to help good causes. A reasonable person could think that means he's not spending his money how you want him to spend it.

1. What insight do you have on how his money is spent? Do you know what he buys? Do you know what charities he has donated to?

2. Does he have the right to dictate how you spend your money? Of course not. Therefore, do you have the right to dictate how he spends his money?

Look, I think the guy is just as much of a toolbag as everyone else here. But before we work ourselves into frenzy, let's pump the brakes a bit. We know very little about this guy other than what we read in these stories. I bet he thinks he is "doing the right thing" and his actions are noble and justified. We just disagree with him. If he is doing what he thinks is "right" does that make him a scumbag? Maybe. Maybe not.

In the end, he should be punished for any laws he broke, and held accountable for his actions.

Expand full comment

Regardless of how he spends his money (which he hopefully won’t have for long because he’ll be sued by the janitor) he’s wasting his time promoting anarchy, when he’d be the first to call the police if someone broke into his home as he’s doing to another’s “home” on the Columbia campus and will be among the first to cry foul when Hamas takes over his property and money.

The irony here is that these useful idiots are the very people Hamas will want to get rid of first….by firing squad or worse….they’re either the idle anarchistic rich (who will be unable to adjust to an authoritarian regime) and/or lesbians, gays, women etc all of whom will have no use (except perhaps as imprisoned slaves -or in the case of women, imprisoned in burkas) to a regime that will see some as immoral infidels to be killed or to be used as idiot slaves or baby breeders to those in charge.

Expand full comment

Bro, I hope he gets enough donation money to quit his job, go to school and get a better one.

Expand full comment

Or SKIP school and start his own business.

Expand full comment

I just donated. But who is David Cohen and how do we know this is going to Mr. Torres?!

Expand full comment

Well, that's a good question. But there IS a button on the Go Fund Me page called "Donation Protected". And I have funded through the site before, with positive results. Personally, I'm going on trust. If you've got a better way to verify, go for it. And let us know!

Expand full comment

I don't trust GoFundMe after what they pulled during the Canadian truck protest. They are all too likely to decide the recipient is too "evil" (not Leftist enough) to deserve the money.

Expand full comment

Sadly, you have a point.

Expand full comment

There is also a contact form on the page to send to David Cohen directly.

Expand full comment

I wonder if there is a way for the interviewer to find out from Mr. Torres whether he 1) knows of the funding, and 2) is getting the funds -- ?

Expand full comment

It's also ironic that Mr. Torres earns $19 an hour. The average salary of faculty at Columbia is about $178,000 a year, or roughly $90 an hour. Many of these faculty members are wonderful teachers and world class researchers, but a significant number of them contribute far less to the university, or anything else for that matter, than Mr. Torres. You can find a lot of those faculty participating in the latest round of "student" demonstrations.

Expand full comment

I donated as well. He was absolutely right to be concerned about losing his job in a month when this has all exited the news cycle- but we need the voices of people like him in our public conversations.

Great interview, Francesca.

Expand full comment

I donated too

Expand full comment
founding

Me too

Expand full comment

You nailed this perfectly.

Expand full comment

How can I make a donation?

Expand full comment

Someone give this man a better job. He's got a good head on his shoulders.

Expand full comment

more than that, some attorney take his case Pro Bono to make sure he isn't retaliated against and is properly compensated for Columbia's failures to protect him and his coworkers.

Expand full comment

It’s a travesty that Torres should need a funding campaign, given that his employer is culpable for not protecting him in the first place.

Expand full comment

well, the union is already representing him so he doesn't need money for that, but an attorney should take his case Pro Bono for a civil suit. Legal representation isn't free (unless you're a socialist).

Expand full comment

Most people who work in the janitorial and property management do. What Mr. Torres and others in those professions should get is a living wage. Which is not $19/hr, especially in NYC.

Expand full comment

But someone has to clean up after the elite toddlers. They should all have their salaries DOUBLED.

Expand full comment

Also, everyone should shun the 40-year-old trust fund protester named James Carlson!

Expand full comment

The 40 year old is not a 'kid', he is an adult with immense resources but prefers to behave like a hooligan, knowing that he can afford the best lawyers and will suffer little consequences.

Compare and contrast that person who enjoys behaving like a spoilt toddler instead of a responsible adult with the man he assaulted.

The janitor who is only 5 years older than this so-called 'kid' behaved with far more sense of purpose. He defended Columbia against the mob. He appears proud of his job and presumably the university where he works, making a mostly unseen and overlooked contribution. In short he is a responsible adult, the sort that America used to pride itself on producing.

Hopefully Columbia will stick up for him and ensure his safe working environment as he stuck up for Columbia in its hour of need.

It would be to Columbia's shame if it failed in this simple task of sifting the wheat from the chaff.

Expand full comment

If Columbia fails this basic test, it has no more claim to exist as an institution of higher learning.

Expand full comment

They've already failed.

Expand full comment

He's a kid like Hunter Biden is a kid.

Their immense privilege means they never have to do any adulting even as time is coming for them to qualify for AARP membership.

Expand full comment

There are reasons why the Founders of the US did not want an aristocracy. Many had come to the US to escape this sort of over entitlement.

People should stop excusing the behaviour. It is not a good look after the age of about 16 (not sure it is a good look even then but you have to allow proper children to make mistakes and then clean up their own messes). It is actually pathetic.

Expand full comment

Don't confuse the issue, and don't make false comparisons.

Expand full comment

Columbia stick up for him? Puuuuleeeease. They got $90k/year clients they're too busy coddling.

Expand full comment

And that should be the Columbia's administration's shame. The only way they will be shamed is if the so-called Fourth Estate starts exposing the way they treat the ordinary employees when things like this occur.

Columbia should also be making the students involved in the trashing of the campus materially assist in cleaning it up -- not only in dollar terms, but also manual labour so they can start to understand what they did. Some will get it. Most won't.

Expand full comment
May 8·edited May 8

They have failed their students and faculty in exactly the same way. They may help this janitor - and only because of this FP article and because his union is suing - but they won't condemn or punish the pro-Hamas mob (thugs) for it. Shafik lied under oath and the university has already capitulated to the mob over and over again.

Expand full comment

The faculty and administration at Columbia may be mostly chaff.

Expand full comment

Notice how organized he said it all was. This is not “peaceful protest”. This is planned insurrection and destruction.

Expand full comment

And unlike January 6th, directed by malign foreign interests whose aim is the destruction of the United States of America. If we had a real FBI, who viewed its job as protecting American citizens, we'd have the answers pretty quickly.

Expand full comment

For better or worse, we've got to get Trump elected. Even at the worst, we'll be the ones to feel good, and they won't.

Expand full comment

Don’t worry, Alan Bragg is right on the case. Not.

Expand full comment

Then they wonder why blue collar workers of all races are voting republican.

Expand full comment

Columbia U Trustee Jeh Johnson was interviewed on Morning Joe. When asked why Columbia didn’t call in the police the way Ben Sasse did at U FL, Jeh admitted that the faculty support the students’ law breaking and violence. So, this is what diversity hiring gets you. Diverse, as in American haters, Islamists. No, we don’t need this kind of diversity.

Expand full comment

I'm not sure it is diversity hiring that gets us here. I think it is conformity hiring.

Expand full comment

Astute point. Diversity means conformity in these Alice in Wonderland days. The left just didn’t think you were smart enough to figure that out. Keep calling them out. They hate that some of us have great hypocrisy radar.

Expand full comment

In other news, MIT today stopped requiring diversity statements from new hires.

Expand full comment

We call it “diverse hiring “ but it’s really just intellectual nepotism. If the janitor has grounds to sue, he should IMO.

Expand full comment

That’s just evil

Expand full comment

This is a guy working a graveyard shift so he can take care of and be there for his kids. With the purest clarity, after being held hostage by an elite mob while he was trying to just do the job he loves, he says,

“to get through this mob just punch into work, why are they still there? This is CRAZY.”

That about sums up what the chattering class that is dismantling and disrespecting those that put boots on to work every day, is at its core.

Expand full comment

^^this^^

Expand full comment

It sounds like they have some sort of training and organization. Groups of "protestors" don't usually carry duct tape and zip ties. They don't cover up cameras first. They don't coordinate attacks from two sides. Someone planned and organized this, and wanted it to turn violent.

Expand full comment

The “protesters “ didn’t even think to pack lunch. You think they thought about cameras?

Expand full comment

Oh, they thought it through. They just assumed that they would have access to their normal resources while destroying their campus

Expand full comment

yes beacseu they knew someone would send pizza ( gate)

Expand full comment

Agree!Antifa’s participation during Berkeley protest suggest that these are not a group of “crazy kids.” They came with weapons, took positions on roof tops, etc. and are ready to deploy their techniques for trees, BLM, or Gaza.

Expand full comment

this article explains it (oh what would be do without FP and Tablet?) Now we know, we have to do something

https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/people-setting-america-on-fire-soros-tides-wespac

Expand full comment

What a contrast! A multi-millionnaire trust fund baby v. a blue collar working stiff. The left does love its social agitators, and snidely stands behind them while pretending they don't. A privileged elite pretending it's fighting for the masses. Power. They are simply seeking power. No better place to find it than on the campuses of our failed academic institutions.

Expand full comment

Time for a group of janitors to occupy a 2.3 million dollar Brooklyn townhouse?

Expand full comment

I hear if you squat for awhile you get to keep it.

Expand full comment

Yes, and it's coming time for much worse than that, sorry to say.

Expand full comment

A case of REAL Oppresser vs Oppressed! Not that the Columbia geniuses will get the irony.

Expand full comment

So this was all planned and funded. Funded by whom? Follow the money. Right up to the top. Then arrest them for felonies. And publish their names. Wanna bet whose involved? These people are the enemies of America. Start treating them accordingly.

Expand full comment

Hasn't it been reported that Biden's biggest donors are some of the funders? Let's see a deep dive into that story!

Expand full comment

Let's see who has the courage to do that? Certainly not any of the left leaning "journalists" with whom we are afflicted.

Expand full comment

To be fair, Politico posted a story about it. Now who will pick it up and amplify it?

Expand full comment

Including Bari Weiss and the Free Press.

Expand full comment
May 7·edited May 7

See this article on Tablet: "The People Setting America on Fire," by Park MacDougald. It was posted yesterday. Trigger warning: It made me feel hopeless.

Expand full comment

ha! i just posted that (3Xs) - great reporting!

Expand full comment

Patrick Bet-David revealed in a Podcast that under 10% of colleges are funded by tuition. The big money donors, like Soros pull the strings. They don't care if students are hurt. They care about the money. It doesn't hurt that the teachers are leftist fools that don't live in the real world and will go along.

Expand full comment

Qatar and China funnel many billions to US university programs…

Expand full comment

It's not protest if the administration supports it.

These cowards with the hoods and masks are following the same playbook you can see for yourselves if you rent Birth of a Nation from the public library. They know, just like the animals featured in that movie, that there is no way in the world they will be held accountable for their acts.

As soon as the media goes away, every single "protester" will be back on campus, no hint of discipline or suspension of any kind.

Expand full comment

Great interview!

"So I’m taking a big risk doing this, but I think that they failed. They failed us. And I think that’s the bigger story. They failed us. They should have done more to protect us, and they didn’t.”

Hey Bari Weiss!

That quotation above pretty much describes every sanctified minority who was bullied into voting for the fucking Democratic Party over the years... I bet that every single "they" he refers to is a registered Democrat. All of them. 100%. Without exception...

How much more will it take for you to declare a fatwah against the Democratic Party?

You're starting to look like Bret Weinstein... a really smart guy who can't admit that he was wrong for about the last 30 fucking years of his life...

Expand full comment

Why do you assume he's a Dem voter? Did he say he was? Reality is most working class black guys in cities like him don't vote. They gave up on government doing anything for them long ago.

Expand full comment

Just consider the framing of your question... "they gave up on government doing anything for them"...

The notion of "government doing things for me" is a sickness.

But I don't presume this guy voted Dem... in my comment, I propose that the "they" in his remarks would only refer to people who, if it were investigate, would turn out to be registered Democrats.

All university failures are failures of the Democratic Party since they have a nearly complete stranglehold on these institutions.

The Free Press keeps trying to frame these issues as "social" problems. They're not. Most of American society is healthy enough. Nearly every single problem, failure or issue highlighted in this publikation stems from one source: Democrats.

Expand full comment
May 7·edited May 7

because the far right and far left together believe all minorities vote the same way. Of course, the far right is hostile to them which overshadows the far left being patronizing to them. The left believes more immigration means more Dem votes so we must bring them in, and the right believes more immigration means more left votes, so we must keep them out. Classic horseshoe theory on display.

If not for the right's overt racism and bigotry more minorities (especially legal Hispanic and Asian immigrants) would recognize the left's covert racism and bigotry towards them, but the far right and Trump just can't help themselves (poisoning the blood).

Expand full comment

Please give us an example of "overt racism and bigotry" from the far right.

Who are they? Name them by name and specific proof.

My bet is you cannot.

Expand full comment

Yes, yes , yes, but oh God, please don't start using their language.

Expand full comment

I am a profane person. It does not change the substance of my critique. Only its flavor.

Expand full comment

Okay. I've always liked you, anyway.

Expand full comment
founding

During riots in ‘68 bf I’d met my husband he was Orthopedic Resident on call at Columbia infirmary. Saw lots of students w contusions and scalp lacerations from encounters w police. Lots of dramatic photos w no one seriously hurt. Only two serious injuries a police officer w spine injury and janitor who had been thrown down stairs in Occupied bldg by students. They required hospitalization w multiple fractures. Story never reported

Expand full comment

Thank you for giving him a safe place to share his story. Mr. Torres does what most of these ignorant, entitled “protestors” wouldn’t consider as a career. Will definitely donate & share the Go Fund Me. Let’s show him the love he deserves!

Expand full comment